2001 James Beard Award Nominee


Restaurant Reviews

Artful Weblog

Artful Weblog

Jersey Shore

The Artful Diner Artful Diner logo
Black bar

Check out ArtfulDinerBlog,com.

6 Roosevelt Avenue
Chatham, Morris County, New Jersey
(973) 701-0303

By The Artful Diner
January 8, 2007

Let me preface my remarks by stating that James and Nancy Laird's Restaurant Serenade is, without doubt, one of New Jersey's finest (and costliest) dining experiences...

Interestingly enough, however, my sojourn here was faintly reminiscent of the situation encountered several years ago when I dined at the Ryland Inn and Nicholas on consecutive evenings. Nicholas was, at the time, not yet six months old, but its cuisine was fresh and vibrant, alive with clarity of purpose and intensity of flavor; in contrast, the Ryland Inn's offerings seemed overly cumbersome and plodding.

More recent circumstances were similar, though not nearly so pronounced, and in reverse order: dinner at Serenade was preceded by an evening at Lorena's in Maplewood. And, once again, a certain degree of comparison/contrast was inevitable. Leaving aside such issues as ambiance and service and concentrating solely on the food, in my opinion, Lorena's cuisine acquitted itself with a good deal more savoir faire. It exhibited a lighter, more sophisticated touch in both its choice of its ingredients and in its presentations.

That is not to say, of course, that Serenade's culinary offerings are in any way to be denigrated. Mr. Laird is certainly a highly acclaimed and accomplished chef, quickly approaching the stratosphere of his chosen profession. His starter of creamless purée of pumpkin soup ($13.00), for example, is nothing short of supernal. The consistency is neither too thick nor too thin, and the infusion of apples, chestnuts, and chives is an absolute marvel of subtle restraint.

On the other hand, his grilled octopus ($15.00) is somewhat heavy handed. Morsels of slightly chewy (as one would expect) octopus are companioned by tender diced potatoes, olive oil, and pinch of preserved lemon. But the presentation lacks flair, does absolutely nothing for the eye and even less for the palate and, as you soon discover, suffers from a surfeit of oil.

The endive salad ($10.00) hits all the right notes, with shaved Asian pears, earthy Roquefort cheese, and molasses-glazed pecans adding to the rich textural complexity. Taste-wise, it cannot be faulted. Once again, however, the presentation is somewhat lackluster, as the various components might have been dropped onto the plate from twenty thousand feet. One does not expect a work of art, but a more attractive display would undoubtedly do wonders to stimulate the appetite.

The crab cakes ($17.00) have a more artistic flair and are quite good... but not AS good as those sampled in numerous other Garden State establishments. They are also over breaded and, in my opinion, overpriced. If you insist upon traveling the seafood route, the fried Maine oysters ($14.00) are pristinely plump and perfectly complemented by a zippy soy-ginger mignonette and superb seaweed salad.

If a restaurant is destined to let you down, disappointment will generally rear its ugly head with the entrées rather than the appetizers. At Serenade, however, the obverse appears to be true, as main courses, for the most part, have infinitely more to offer than their predecessors.

The filet mignon ($35.00), for example, is absolutely benchmark. The beef is magnificently tender, its pillow of potato purée positively addictive, and the accompanying peppercorn sauce a profound culinary catalyst. The pork (a special entrée offered as part of the Friday evening prix fixe), which has been known to turn dry at the drop of a fork, is undeniably moist and succulent; unfortunately, its pairing with a mound of lemon thyme risotto is a rather ill-conceived marriage and not terribly edifying to the eye.

On the seafood front, the pan-roasted sea bass ($34.00) hits all the right notes: The flesh is delicate and flaky; and the topping of apples, cucumbers, capers, and tomatoes is just assertive enough without overpowering the fish's own natural flavor.

Calf's liver is a dish I dearly love but order only occasionally -- and with good reason. Though its preparation is relatively simple, it is still quite easy to muck up. For starters, if improperly trimmed, it can be off-puttingly fibrous; secondly, depending upon the predilection of the chef, it is apt to put in a well-timed appearance either bleeding on the server's socks or as tough as shoe leather. Finally, I prefer my liver au naturel, or at least gussied up as little as possible; and that is exceedingly difficult to come by as it is generally smothered in onions and/or bacon or drowned in a God-awful vinegary concoction.

That being said, however, let me hasten to add that Mr. Laird's version is a superlative effort. The liver is prepared to a perfect compromise between medium and medium rare and exhibits an appetizingly silken texture. Refreshingly unadorned, its thick slices recline on a bed of peas and green & yellow beans; a luscious bacon-onion tartlet and superlative cassis sauce provide first-rate complementary touches.

Desserts here ($10.00) are quite good; and the best bet is also the simplest: homemade ice creams and sorbets. Recently sampled was an outstanding rum raisin ice cream presented on a disc of caramelized phyllo with a garnish of fresh fruit. Other standouts include a homey cobbler -- in whatever seasonal guise it may appear -- and a pecan-crusted warm chocolate tart embellished with a dollop of vanilla ice cream.

Serenade's wine list, as you would expect, is world-class -- and pricey. A savvy oenophile may be able to discover a few reasonably priced gems... but I wouldn't count on it. Even vintage offerings by the glass may end up putting a hefty dent in your wallet. A 2003 Chassagne-Montrachet from Michel Colin-Deléger, for instance, will set you back $19.00; and a 1999 Santenay "Les Gravières" 1er Cru from the same producer will cause $16.00 worth of damage. Both, of course, are of excellent quality. Other offerings in the $8.00 - $10.00 range are not nearly so impressive.

And speaking of prices... There is absolutely no question that Serenade would never be considered a cheap date. As you have undoubtedly noticed, the à la carte menu features appetizers in the mid and upper teens, salads and desserts priced at $10.00 per, and only two entrées below the $30.00 mark. The "Market Menu" and "Seafood Celebration," chef's tasting menus, weigh in at $80.00 per person, $115.00 per person with wine pairings. No wonder the weekend $59.00 three-course prix fixe (which also includes coffee or tea) is considered such a bargain, although lobster and rack of lamb carry hefty $8.00 supplements.

But there are other factors at work... On a recent visit, the Maître d' led our party of five through the nearly empty, much-preferred cathedral-ceilinged main dining room down a few steps to a lower dining area, which, I quickly noticed, was soon to be shared by a party of 12 - 15 -- and subsequently was, replete with a boisterous, peripatetic clientele flashing away with abandon to capture the moment. We were seated next to the gas fireplace that the Maître d' described as "cozy." And it might well have been, had our table not be situated in direct earshot, eyeshot, and noseshot of the nearby kitchen door, through which there passed a never-ending stream of various and sundry restaurant personnel. Cozy? It think not.

Needless to say, we immediately asked for a change of venue and were promptly seated in the main dining area. Our aforementioned abode is obviously the least desirable table in the house, hence the restaurant attempts to fill it as quickly as possible. But when one makes reservations well in advance, arrives early in the evening, and notes that the establishment is the next thing to empty, being shuffled off to Siberia is somewhat disconcerting.

And speaking of disconcerting... this brings us inevitably to Serenade's service, which, in March of 2003, David Corcoran of the NJ section of the New York Times described as "attentive, though it can feel brittle and overrehearsed." If anything, the situation has actually degenerated. Members of the wait staff position themselves like a phalanx of self-conscious penguins auditioning for bit parts in A Chorus Line, their facial features locked in a carefully controlled cybernetic countenance. No matter what stage of your meal, you imagine their eyes boring into you, ready to swoop in and deprive you of sustenance at the drop of a fork. The service is, in short, intrusive to a fault. Interestingly enough, however, when I was trying desperately to order a glass of wine at the outset of dinner, all attentions appeared to be focused elsewhere.

The big question, of course, is to be found at the bottom line: Is Serenade worth its not insignificant price tag? Portion sizes are certainly ample (at times, almost too ample) and, in my opinion, presentations could demonstrate a tad more sophistication, so I seriously doubt that anyone will feel short-changed. And, given the upscale surroundings, this establishment is the perfect venue for those who wish to splurge on that special occasion. So I guess the answer is, very simply: It depends on who's picking up the tab. If you are, bring the platinum card or a substantial amount of long green.

Cuisine: American with French Accents
Hours: Lunch: Mon - Fri, 12:00 noon - 2 p.m.; Dinner: Mon - Fri, 6:00 p.m. - 9:00 p.m.; Sat, 5:30 p.m. - 10:00 p.m.; Sun, 5:00 p.m. - 9:00 p.m.
Credit Cards: All major
Attire: Business Casual
Reservations: Recommended
Parking: Valet
Alcohol: License; extensive and pricey wine list
Price: Expensive
Handicapped Accessible: Yes
Website: www.restaurantserenade.com

Want to receive e-mail notification when a new review or article is posted? E-mail The Artful Diner!

Black bar
Home Reviews Artful Blogger